A PAPER PRESENTED BY PROF ABIODUN AMUDA-KANNIKE SAN, JP, FCArb, FCIAP, FIIHP, ACTI, ACSP, LFWLS, AG DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF LEGISLATIVE SUPPORT SERVICES (DLSS), OF THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR LEGISLATIVE AND DEMOCRATIC STUDIES (NILDS) ABUJA AND THE PIONEER DEAN, FACULTY OF LAW, KWARA STATE UNIVERSITY, MALETE, VIA -ILORIN KWARA STATE, THE SAID PRESENTATION WHICH TOOK PLACE AT FACULTY OF LAW, NNAMDI AZIKIWE UNIVERSITY, AWKA, ANAMBRA STATE OF NIGERIA, 2ND INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE (HYBRID) ON THE 14TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2025.
Tel: 08033256756
Email: amudakannikeabiodun@gmail.com
Abstract
The future of trade in Nigeria’s digital transformation era requires a robust legal framework to address emerging challenges and opportunities. This presentation explores the legal effects of digital transformation on trade in Nigeria, examining the current state of digital transformation, relevant laws and regulations, and emerging issues and challenges. It proposes recommendations for a robust legal framework, including amendments to existing laws and regulations, development of new laws and policies, and institutional capacity building. The presentation aims to contribute to the ongoing discourse on digital trade and governance in Nigeria, providing insights for stakeholders to navigate the complexities of digital transformation.
Keywords: Digital transformation, Trade, Legal Framework, Digital trade, E-commerce, cybersecurity.
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The world is witnessing a rapid digital transformation, driven by technological advancements, changing consumer behaviors, and the need for businesses and governments to adapt to a rapidly evolving global landscape. Nigeria, Africa’s largest economy and most populous country, is no exception to this trend. Digital transformation is revolutionizing various sectors in Nigeria, including finance, commerce, education, and healthcare, and is expected to play a critical role in the country’s economic development.
1.2 BACKGROUND ON DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN NIGERIA
Nigeria’s digital economy is growing rapidly, driven by a large and increasing youth population, improving digital infrastructure, and increasing adoption of digital technologies. According to a report by the World Bank, Nigeria’s digital economy has grown to $52 billion in 2025, creating millions of jobs and opportunities for economic growth.[1] The Nigerian government has also launched several initiatives aimed at promoting digital transformation, including the National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy, which aims to create a digital economy that is vibrant, innovative, and globally competitive.[2]
1.3 IMPORTANCE OF TRADE IN DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
Trade plays a crucial role in digital transformation, enabling countries to access new markets, technologies, and innovations. In Nigeria, trade in digital services can help drive economic growth, create jobs, and improve living standards. Digital trade can also facilitate the exchange of goods and services, increase market access, and enhance economic competitiveness.[3] According to a report by the World Trade Organization (WTO), digital trade can help reduce trade costs, increase efficiency, and promote economic development.[4] In Nigeria, the growth of digital trade has the potential to unlock new economic opportunities, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and entrepreneurs.[5]
1.4 STATEMENT ABOUT THE WORK
This work argues that the future of trade in Nigeria’s digital transformation era requires a robust legal framework that addresses emerging challenges and opportunities, promotes digital trade, and ensures the protection of rights and interests of stakeholders. A well-designed legal framework will enable Nigeria to harness the benefits of digital transformation, while minimizing its risks and challenges.[6] As noted by scholars, a robust legal framework is essential for promoting digital trade and ensuring that its benefits are shared by all.[7]
2.1 OVERVIEW OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN NIGERIA
Digital transformation is revolutionizing various sectors in Nigeria, including finance, commerce, education, and healthcare. The country is witnessing a rapid growth in digital technologies, including mobile phones, the internet, and digital payments.
2.2 CURRENT STATE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN NIGERIA
Nigeria’s digital economy is growing rapidly, with a significant increase in internet penetration, mobile phone adoption, and digital transactions. According to a report by the Nigeria Communications Commission (NCC), the country’s internet penetration rate stood at approximately 63% as of 2022, with over 109 million internet users.[8] Mobile phone penetration is also high, with over 200 million mobile subscribers in the country.[9] The growth of digital payments is also notable, with the value of transactions increasing by over 50% in 2020 alone.[10]
2.3 KEY DRIVERS OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION
Several factors are driving digital transformation in Nigeria, including:
Technological advancements: The rapid development and adoption of digital technologies, such as artificial intelligence, blockchain, and the Internet of Things (IoT), are transforming businesses and industries in Nigeria.[11] Changing consumer behavior: Nigerian consumers are increasingly adopting digital channels to access goods and services, driving demand for digital solutions.[12] Government initiatives: The Nigerian government has launched several initiatives aimed at promoting digital transformation, including the National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy.[13] Entrepreneurship and innovation: Nigeria’s thriving startup ecosystem and entrepreneurial culture are driving innovation and digital transformation in the country.[14] Investment in digital infrastructure: Investments in digital infrastructure, such as fiber optic cables and data centers, are improving access to digital services and driving digital transformation.[15]
2.4 OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN NIGERIA
Digital transformation presents numerous opportunities for Nigeria, including:
Economic growth: Digital transformation can drive economic growth, create new job opportunities, and increase GDP.[16] Improved access to services: Digital transformation can improve access to healthcare, education, and financial services, particularly for underserved communities.[17] Increased efficiency: Digital transformation can increase efficiency and productivity in various sectors, including agriculture, manufacturing, and logistics.[18]
However, digital transformation also poses several challenges, including:
Cybersecurity threats: Digital transformation increases the risk of cybersecurity threats, including data breaches and cyberattacks.[19] Digital divide: Digital transformation can exacerbate the digital divide, particularly in rural areas with limited access to digital infrastructure.[20] Regulatory challenges: Digital transformation poses regulatory challenges, including the need for updated laws and regulations to govern digital transactions and data protection.[21]
3.0 LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR DIGITAL TRADE IN NIGERIA
3.1 OVERVIEW OF RELEVANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS
Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act 2015: This law prohibits and punishes cybercrimes, including hacking, phishing, and identity theft.[22] National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy 2020-2030: This policy aims to promote digital trade, innovation, and entrepreneurship in Nigeria.[23] Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019: This regulation protects personal data and ensures that companies handling personal data comply with certain standards.[24] Electronic Transactions Bill: This bill aims to facilitate electronic transactions and promote digital trade in Nigeria.[25] Consumer Protection Act: This law protects consumers in digital transactions and ensures that they are treated fairly.[26]
These laws and regulations provide a framework for digital trade in Nigeria, but there is still a need for further development and harmonization to ensure that they are effective in promoting digital trade.
3.2 ANALYSIS OF EXISTING LEGAL FRAMEWORKS FOR DIGITAL TRADE IN NIGERIA
Nigeria’s existing legal frameworks for digital trade are a step in the right direction, but they have several limitations and gaps. Here’s a critical analysis of the existing frameworks:
Lack of comprehensive legislation: Nigeria lacks a comprehensive legislation that specifically regulates digital trade. The Cybercrimes Act 2015 is limited in scope and focuses primarily on cybercrime prevention and prosecution.[27] Inadequate data protection: The Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019 is a positive development, but it is not a legislation and lacks the force of law. Moreover, its implementation has been slow, and there is a need for more robust data protection laws.[28] Insufficient consumer protection: The Consumer Protection Act provides some protections for consumers, but it does not specifically address digital transactions. There is a need for more comprehensive consumer protection laws that address digital transactions.[29] Unclear tax regime: The tax regime for digital transactions is unclear, and there is a need for clear guidelines on taxation of digital transactions.[30] Limited cross-border data flows: Nigeria’s laws and regulations do not provide clear guidelines on cross-border data flows, which can create uncertainty for businesses and hinder digital trade.[31]
To address these limitations and gaps, Nigeria needs to develop a comprehensive legal framework that addresses the unique challenges and opportunities of digital trade. This framework should include:
Comprehensive digital trade legislation: Nigeria should enact a comprehensive legislation that regulates digital trade and addresses issues such as data protection, consumer protection, and taxation.
Robust data protection laws: Nigeria should enact robust data protection laws that provide adequate protection for personal data and ensure that companies handling personal data comply with certain standards.
Clear guidelines on taxation: Nigeria should provide clear guidelines on taxation of digital transactions to ensure certainty and predictability for businesses.
Facilitating cross-border data flows: Nigeria should develop laws and regulations that facilitate cross-border data flows and ensure that data can be transferred securely and efficiently.
3.3 GAPS AND CHALLENGES IN THE CURRENT LEGAL FRAMEWORK
The current legal framework for digital trade in Nigeria has several gaps and challenges that need to be addressed to facilitate the growth of the digital economy. Some of the key gaps and challenges include:[32]
Lack of Comprehensive Legislation: Nigeria lacks a comprehensive legislation that specifically regulates digital trade, leading to ambiguity and uncertainty in the application of laws and regulations.[33] Inadequate Data Protection: The Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019 is not a legislation and lacks the force of law, making it difficult to enforce data protection standards.[34] Insufficient Consumer Protection: The Consumer Protection Act provides some protections for consumers, but it does not specifically address digital transactions, leaving consumers vulnerable to exploitation.[35] Unclear Tax Regime: The tax regime for digital transactions is unclear, leading to uncertainty and potential tax evasion.[36] Limited Cross-Border Data Flows: Nigeria’s laws and regulations do not provide clear guidelines on cross-border data flows, making it difficult for businesses to operate seamlessly across borders.[37] Weak Cybersecurity Infrastructure: Nigeria faces significant cybersecurity threats, including data breaches and cyberattacks, which can compromise the integrity of digital transactions.[38] Inadequate Regulatory Framework for Fintech: The regulatory framework for fintech in Nigeria is fragmented, with multiple agencies regulating different aspects of fintech, leading to confusion and overlap.[39] Lack of Standardization: There is a lack of standardization in the regulation of digital trade, leading to confusion and inconsistency in the application of laws and regulations.[40] Limited Global Coordination: Nigeria’s limited participation in global coordination efforts, such as the OECD’s BEPS, limits its ability to shape global tax policies and protect its interests.[41] Public Trust and Compliance Culture: There is a need to improve public trust and compliance culture in Nigeria, particularly in the area of taxation, to ensure that digital trade contributes to the country’s economic development.[42]
To address these gaps and challenges, Nigeria needs to develop a comprehensive legal framework that addresses the unique challenges and opportunities of digital trade. This framework should include:[43]
Comprehensive Digital Trade Legislation: Enacting a comprehensive legislation that regulates digital trade and addresses issues such as data protection, consumer protection, and taxation.[44] Robust Data Protection Laws: Enacting robust data protection laws that provide adequate protection for personal data and ensure that companies handling personal data comply with certain standards.[45] Clear Guidelines on Taxation: Providing clear guidelines on taxation of digital transactions to ensure certainty and predictability for businesses.[46] Facilitating Cross-Border Data Flows: Developing laws and regulations that facilitate cross-border data flows and ensure that data can be transferred securely and efficiently.[47] Strengthening Cybersecurity Infrastructure: Investing in robust cybersecurity infrastructure to protect digital transactions and prevent cyber threats.[48] Improving Regulatory Framework for Fintech: Developing a more cohesive and comprehensive regulatory framework for fintech to promote innovation and protect consumers.[49] Enhancing Global Coordination: Enhancing Nigeria’s participation in global coordination efforts to shape global tax policies and protect its interests.[50] Improving Public Trust and Compliance Culture: Improving public trust and compliance culture in Nigeria, particularly in the area of taxation, to ensure that digital trade contributes to the country’s economic development.[51]
4.0 LEGAL EFFECTS OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION ON TRADE IN NIGERIA
4.1 IMPACT OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION ON CONTRACT LAW AND DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Digital transformation has significantly impacted trade in Nigeria, particularly in contract law and dispute resolution. Here are some key effects:
4.1.1 Contract Law
Electronic Contracts: Online contracts are increasingly common in Nigeria’s digital commerce landscape. The Evidence Act 2011 recognizes electronically generated evidence, while the Cybercrimes Act 2015 addresses digital transaction security.[52] Enforceability: Nigerian courts enforce online agreements based on traditional contract principles, but digital platforms introduce complexities related to consent, evidence, and verification.[53] Legislative Framework: The Electronic Transactions Act 2023 aims are to formalize e-signatures and online agreements, aligning Nigeria with international best global practices.[54]
4.1.2 Dispute Resolution
Virtual Mediation and Online Arbitration: Technology-driven dispute resolution methods are gaining traction in Nigeria. Virtual mediation involves resolving disputes through online platforms, while online arbitration uses digital tools to facilitate arbitration proceedings.[55] Benefits: These methods offer flexibility, reduced costs, and increased accessibility, making dispute resolution more efficient and convenient.[56] Challenges: Technical issues, data security, and jurisdictional concerns are some of the challenges associated with online dispute resolution.[57]
4.1.3 Key Challenges
Lack of Comprehensive Legislation: Nigeria lacks a comprehensive legislation regulating digital trade, leading to ambiguity and uncertainty.[58] Inadequate Data Protection: The Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019 lacks the force of law, making it difficult to enforce data protection standards.[59] Insufficient Consumer Protection: The Consumer Protection Act provides some protections, but it does not specifically address digital transactions.[60]
4.2 DATA PROTECTION AND PRIVACY ISSUES IN THE DIGITAL TRADE
Data protection and privacy issues are crucial in digital trade, particularly in Nigeria. The country has taken significant steps to address these concerns through legislation and regulation.
4.2.1 Key Issues
Inadequate Data Protection: Nigeria’s data protection landscape is still evolving, and the country lacks comprehensive legislation regulating digital trade.[61] Data Breaches: Unauthorized access to personal data is a significant risk, and organizations must implement robust security measures to prevent breaches.[62] Cross-Border Data Transfers: Nigeria has rules governing cross-border data transfers, requiring organizations to ensure adequate safeguards are in place.[63] Consent and Transparency: Organizations must obtain informed consent from individuals before collecting and processing their personal data.[64]
4.2.2 Regulatory Framework
Nigeria Data Protection Act (NDPA) 2023: This law regulates data protection in Nigeria, providing guidelines for data controllers and processors.[65] Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC): The NDPC is responsible for enforcing data protection laws and regulations in Nigeria.[66] General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR): Although an EU regulation, GDPR principles influence Nigeria’s data protection framework, particularly regarding cross-border data transfers.[67]
4.2.3 Challenges and Opportunities
Low Awareness: Many Nigerians and organizations are still unaware of their data protection obligations and rights.[68] Regulatory Fatigue: Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) may struggle to comply with data protection regulations.[69] Emerging Technologies: The increasing use of artificial intelligence, biometrics, and other emerging technologies poses new challenges for data protection.[70]
4.2.4 Best Practices
Implement Robust Security Measures: Organizations should prioritize data security and implement measures to prevent data breaches.[71] Obtain Informed Consent: Organizations must obtain explicit consent from individuals before collecting and processing their personal data.[72] Develop Clear Data Protection Policies: Organizations should develop and communicate clear data protection policies to individuals and stakeholders.[73]
4.3 INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS IN DIGITAL ECONOMY
Intellectual property rights (IPR) play a crucial role in the digital economy, protecting innovations and creative works. In Nigeria, IPR laws and regulations are evolving to address digital challenges.
4.3.1 Key Issues
Digital Piracy: Unauthorized use and distribution of digital content, such as music, movies, and software, pose significant challenges to IPR holders.[74] Copyright Infringement: Online platforms and social media have increased the risk of copyright infringement, making it essential to protect creative works.[75] Trademark Protection: Brands and businesses must protect their trademarks in the digital space to maintain their reputation and prevent counterfeiting.[76] Patent Protection: Innovations and inventions in the digital economy require robust patent protection to encourage innovation and investment.[77]
4.3.2 Regulatory Framework
Copyright Act: Nigeria’s Copyright Act protects literary, musical, and artistic works, including digital content.[78] Trademarks Act: The Trademarks Act protects distinctive signs, symbols, and logos used in trade and commerce.[79] Patents and Designs Act: This law protects inventions and designs, including those related to digital technologies.[80]
4.3.3 Challenges and Opportunities
Digital Enforcement: Enforcing IPR in the digital environment poses significant challenges, including jurisdictional issues and the anonymous nature of online activities.[81] Emerging Technologies: New technologies, such as blockchain and artificial intelligence, offer opportunities for innovation but also raise complex IPR issues.[82] International Cooperation: Collaboration between countries and international organizations is essential for effective IPR protection and enforcement in the digital economy.[83]
4.3.4 Best Practices
Register IPR: Businesses and creators should register their IPR to protect their rights and interests.[84] Use Contracts and Agreements: Clear contracts and agreements can help define ownership and usage rights for digital content and innovations.[85] Monitor and Enforce IPR: Regular monitoring and enforcement of IPR are crucial to prevent infringement and protect business interests.[86]
4.4 TAXATION AND REVENUE IMPLICATIONS OF DIGITAL TRADE
Digital trade taxation has become a crucial aspect of international trade, with countries implementing various tax regulations to capture revenue from digital transactions. Here’s an overview of the taxation and revenue implications of digital trade:
4.4.1 Key Taxation Issues in Digital Trade
Value-Added Tax (VAT): Many countries, including Nigeria, have implemented VAT on digital services provided by foreign suppliers.[87] For instance, Nigeria applies a 7.5% VAT on foreign providers, with a registration threshold of NGN 25,000.[88] Digital Services Tax (DST): Some countries have introduced DST, which targets digital businesses that earn revenue from users in their territory.[89] For example, the European Union has proposed a DST on revenues from certain digital services.[90] Withholding Tax: Some countries require digital service providers to withhold taxes on payments made to foreign suppliers.[91]
4.4.2 Country-Specific Tax Regulations
Nigeria: Applies a 7.5% VAT on foreign providers, with a registration threshold of NGN 25,000.[92] United Kingdom: Imposes a 20% VAT on digital services, with no registration threshold.[93] India: Levies an 18% GST on digital services, with no threshold for tax registration.[94] United States: Some states charge sales tax on SaaS registrations, while others use withholding tax or payment providers to collect taxes.[95]
4.4.3 Challenges and Opportunities
Tax Evasion: Digital trade poses challenges for tax authorities to track transactions and prevent tax evasion.[96] Double Taxation: The lack of clarity on tax jurisdiction and allocation can lead to double taxation.[97] Revenue Generation: Digital trade taxation can generate significant revenue for governments, but requires effective implementation and enforcement.[98]
4.4.4 Best Practices
Clear Tax Regulations: Countries should establish clear tax regulations and guidelines for digital trade.[99] International Cooperation: Collaboration between countries is essential to address tax challenges and avoid double taxation.[100] Technology: Leveraging technology can help tax authorities track transactions and improve tax compliance.[101]
5.0 EMERGING ISSUES AND CHALLENGES
5.1 CYBERSECURITY THREATS AND DIGITAL TRADE
Cybersecurity threats in digital trade are becoming increasingly sophisticated, posing significant risks to individuals, organizations, and governments worldwide. Some emerging issues and challenges include:[102]
AI-Powered Cyber Attacks: Cybercriminals are leveraging artificial intelligence to automate phishing campaigns, detect vulnerabilities, and evade security measures.[103] AI-generated malware can adapt to evade detection, making it challenging for traditional security systems to keep up.
Ransomware Attacks: Ransomware attacks have surged in frequency and complexity, with attackers demanding significant payments for decryption keys.[104] These attacks can paralyze critical systems, leading to substantial financial losses and operational disruptions.
Deepfake Scams: Cybercriminals are using AI-generated voices and videos to impersonate executives, orchestrating fraudulent transactions worth millions.[105] Deepfakes can also spread disinformation, further exacerbating cybersecurity threats.
Cloud Security Risks: Misconfigured cloud services and unpatched vulnerabilities can expose organizations to significant risks.[106] Cloud security breaches can result in data loss, financial theft, and reputational damage.
Internet of Things (IoT) Attacks: IoT devices often lack robust security features, making them susceptible to attacks.[107] Compromised IoT devices can be used to create botnets, launch DDoS attacks, or steal sensitive data.
Supply Chain Attacks: Supply chain attacks involve exploiting trusted relationships to breach multiple entities through a single attack.[108] These attacks can be particularly devastating, as they can compromise entire ecosystems.
Social Engineering: Social engineering attacks exploit human psychology, tricking individuals into divulging sensitive information or performing certain actions.[109] Phishing, pretexting, and baiting are common social engineering tactics.
Zero-Day Exploits: Zero-day exploits involve attacking previously unknown vulnerabilities, making them challenging to defend against.[110] Attackers can exploit these vulnerabilities to gain unauthorized access to systems or data.
To combat these threats, organizations should:
Implement robust security measures, such as multi-factor authentication, encryption, and firewalls.[111] Conduct regular security audits and penetration testing.[112] Develop incident response plans and conduct employee training.[113] Stay informed about emerging threats and update security protocols accordingly.[114] Adopt a zero-trust security model and implement advanced threat detection systems.[115] Prioritize cybersecurity governance and compliance.[116]
5.2 DIGITAL PAYMENT SYSTEMS AND FINANCIAL REGULATION
Digital payment systems are revolutionizing the way transactions are conducted, offering convenience and speed. However, they also raise significant regulatory challenges related to security, consumer privacy, and operational risks.
5.2.1 Key Regulatory Areas
Security Regulations: Ensuring secure transaction protocols to protect consumer data, such as encryption standards and fraud prevention measures.[117] Data Protection and Privacy Laws: Compliance with laws like GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) and CCPA (California Consumer Privacy Act) to safeguard user data.[118] Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know-Your-Customer (KYC): Regulations to prevent financial crimes and ensure the legitimacy of transactions.[119] Interoperability Standards: Promoting compatibility among different payment systems for seamless transactions.[120] Consumer Protection: Guidelines for fair practices, dispute resolution, and transparency in payment services.[121]
5.2.2 Regulatory Frameworks
Payment Services Directive 2 (PSD2): An EU regulation that improves payment security and promotes innovation through strong customer authentication and open banking.[122] Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS): A set of rules for securing cardholder data.[123]
5.2.3 Challenges and Opportunities
Digital Financial Literacy: Enhancing consumers’ understanding of digital payment risks and benefits.[124] Cybersecurity: Protecting against online fraud, phishing, and data breaches.[125] Financial Inclusion: Expanding access to digital payment systems for underserved populations.[126]
5.2.4 Global Developments
The growth of digital payments is driven by increased adoption in developing economies and the rise of mobile payment systems.[127] Regulatory bodies are working to balance innovation with security and consumer protection.[128]
5.3 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND AUTOMATION IN DIGITAL TRADE
Artificial intelligence (AI) and automation are transforming digital trade, enhancing efficiency, and reducing costs. Key aspects include:
5.3.1 AI in Digital Trade
Predictive Analytics: AI-powered predictive analytics help businesses forecast demand, manage inventory, and optimize supply chains.[129] Chatbots and Virtual Assistants: AI-driven chatbots provide customer support, improve user experience, and automate tasks.[130] Language Translation: AI-powered language translation tools facilitate cross-border communication and expand market reach.[131]
5.3.2 Automation in Digital Trade
Automated Supply Chain Management: Automation streamlines supply chain operations, reducing errors and increasing efficiency.[132] Robotic Process Automation (RPA): RPA automates repetitive tasks, freeing up resources for strategic activities.[133] Digital Workflows: Automated digital workflows enhance collaboration, reduce paperwork, and improve productivity.[134]
5.3.3 Benefits and Challenges
Increased Efficiency: AI and automation reduce manual labor, increase productivity, and enhance accuracy.[135] Improved Customer Experience: AI-powered tools provide personalized support and enhance user experience.[136] Job Displacement: Automation may displace certain jobs, requiring workers to acquire new skills.[137]
5.3.4 Future Outlook
Integration with Emerging Technologies: AI and automation will integrate with emerging technologies like blockchain, IoT, and 5G, further transforming digital trade.[138] Regulatory Frameworks: Governments will need to develop regulatory frameworks to address AI and automation’s impact on digital trade.[139]
5.4 CROSS-BORDER DATA FLOWS AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE AGREEMENTS
Cross-border data flows have become a crucial aspect of international trade, with countries seeking to balance the free flow of data with regulatory frameworks that protect personal data and national security. International trade agreements play a significant role in shaping the rules governing cross-border data flows.
5.4.1 Key Agreements and Provisions
Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP): Article 14.11 requires parties to allow cross-border transfers of data, subject to domestic regulatory requirements and proportionate measures.[140] United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA): Article 19.11 prohibits restrictions on cross-border data transfers, including personal information, for business purposes.[141] Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP): Chapter 12 on electronic commerce provides for cross-border data flows, while allowing for exceptions for regulatory requirements and national security.[142] EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR): Balances the free flow of data with the protection of personal data rights, imposing restrictions on cross-border data transfers.[143]
5.4.2 Challenges and Limitations
Balancing Free Flow and Regulation: Countries struggle to balance the need for free data flow with regulatory requirements, such as data protection and national security.[144] Divergent Regulatory Frameworks: Different countries have varying regulatory frameworks, making it challenging to establish common standards for cross-border data flows.[145] WTO Governance: The World Trade Organization (WTO) plays a crucial role in governing cross-border data flows, but its agreements and frameworks are often criticized for being outdated and inadequate[146]
5.4.3 Future Directions
International Cooperation: Countries are exploring new ways to cooperate on cross-border data flows, including through regional and plurilateral agreements.[147] Regulatory Convergence: Efforts to establish common standards and frameworks for cross-border data flows are underway, including the EU’s digital trade agreements.[148] WTO Reform: The WTO is working to update its agreements and frameworks to better address the challenges of digital trade and cross-border data flows.[149]
6.1 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR A ROBUST LEGAL FRAMEWORK
To establish a robust legal framework for digital trade, consider the following recommendations:
Clear Definitions and Scope: Define key terms and clarify the scope of the framework to ensure consistency and applicability.
Data Protection and Privacy: Implement robust data protection and privacy regulations, including consent requirements, data minimization, and security measures.
Cross-Border Data Flows: Establish clear rules for cross-border data transfers, including provisions for data localization, encryption, and international cooperation.
Cybersecurity: Develop comprehensive cybersecurity regulations, including incident reporting, risk management, and security standards.
Intellectual Property Protection: Strengthen intellectual property protection, including copyright, trademark, and patent laws, to incentivize innovation.
Consumer Protection: Implement consumer protection regulations, including transparency, disclosure, and dispute resolution mechanisms.
Dispute Resolution: Establish effective dispute resolution mechanisms, including arbitration and mediation, to resolve digital trade disputes.
Regulatory Cooperation: Foster international regulatory cooperation to promote consistency and reduce regulatory barriers.
Flexibility and Adaptability: Ensure the legal framework is flexible and adaptable to evolving digital technologies and trade practices.
Capacity Building: Provide capacity-building programs to enhance understanding and implementation of the legal framework.
Stakeholder Engagement: Engage with stakeholders, including businesses, civil society, and academia, to inform the development and implementation of the legal framework.
By following these recommendations, countries can establish a robust legal framework that supports digital trade while protecting public interests and promoting economic growth.
6.2 CONCLUSION
In conclusion, establishing a robust legal framework for digital trade is crucial for promoting economic growth, protecting public interests, and fostering international cooperation. By implementing clear definitions and scope, data protection and privacy regulations, cross-border data flow rules, cybersecurity measures, intellectual property protection, consumer protection, dispute resolution mechanisms, regulatory cooperation, flexibility, capacity building, and stakeholder engagement, countries can create a framework that supports digital trade while addressing its challenges. Ultimately, a well-designed legal framework will enable countries to harness the benefits of digital trade, promote innovation, and improve the lives of citizens worldwide.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Amuda-Kannike SAN et al; The intersection of technology…; see https://journals.unizik.edu.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 7am
Amuda-Kannike SAN; Data Protection; Aremu Commends Amuda-Kannike on paper; see https://independent.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 10am.
Blockchain and intellectual property report; https://www.wipo.int; Accessed on 4/10/25 at 1:05am
Reed, “Making Laws for the Digital Economy” (2019) (emphasizing the importance of a well-designed legal framework for digital trade); AI overview; Accessed on 20/9/2025 at 1:15am
Central Bank of Nigeria, “Digital Payments in Nigeria” (2022).
Central Bank of Nigeria, “Fintech Regulatory Framework”; see https://www.globallegalsights.com; Accessed on 22/09/25 at 3am.
Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), Article 14.11.
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) guidelines on payment services; https://www.consumerfinance.gov; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 8:30am
Copyright Act, Cap. C28, LFN 2022 (Nigeria).
Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act 2015.
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), “Emerging Threats”; https://www.europa.eu; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 6:06am.
Electronic Transactions Act, 2023.
Emerging technologies and data protection report 2025; https://www.cyberark.com; Accessed on 2/10/2025 at 3:15am
European Commission, “Digital Services Tax” (2020).
EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR); https://gdpr.info.eu; Accessed on 17/10/25 at 2:27am
Evidence Act 2011; Cybercrimes Act 2015.
Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act, 2018, Section 17.
Federal Republic of Nigeria, “National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy” (2020 – 2030); see https://nitda.gov.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 3:15am
Financial Action Task Force (FATF) recommendations on AML/KYC; https://www.fatf.gafi.org; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 6:15am.
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), EU 2016/679.
General Data Protection Regulation, Article 6.
Google Translate and language translation tools; https://translate.google.com; Accessed 7/10/25 at 12:45pm
Ike Oraegbunam, P.I. Ozioko; Protection of Data Base and Computer Generated Works under the Nigerian law; see IJOCLLEP 3, 38, 2021.
IMF, “Digital Trade Taxation”; https://www.imf.org; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 2:03am
Income Tax Act, Cap. I8, LFN 2004 (Nigeria).
India, Goods and Services Tax Act 2017.
International Chamber of Commerce, “Digital Piracy Report” (2020); https://iccwbo.org; Accessed on 3/10/25 at 3:40am
ISO 27001, Information Security Management System; https://www.alison.com; Accessed on 3/10/25 at 3am
Lack of comprehensive digital trade legislation in Nigeria; https://aamdalelaw.com; Accessed on 1/10/25 at 3am.
McKinsey & Company, “Digital Transformation in Africa” (2020); see https://archive.umeca.org; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 1:30am
Multi-factor authentication and encryption.
National Information Technology Development Agency, “Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019” (2019).
Nigeria Communications Commission, “Internet Penetration in Nigeria” (2022).
Nigeria Data Protection Act (NDPA) 2023.
Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC), “About Us”; https://ndpc.gov.ng; Accessed 2/10/25 at 2am.
Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019, Section 5.
Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019, which provides some guidelines on cross-border data transfers, but is limited in scope.
Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019.
Nigeria, Finance Act 2023.
Nigerian courts’ decisions on online contracts; https://law.unn.edu.ng; Accessed on 1/10/25 at 2:05am
OECD, “Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)”; see https://www.oecd.org; Accessed on 23/09/25 at 1:05am
OECD, “Digital Economy Outlook 2020” (2020).
OECD, “Technology and Tax Administration”; https://www.oecd.org; Accessed on 6/10/2025 at 4:02am
Patents and Designs Act, Cap. P2, LFN 2022 (Nigeria).
Amuda-Kannike SAN; Data Protection Laws in Nigeria: Impacts; see https://journals.kwasu.edu.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 5am
PwC, “Global Consumer Insights Survey” (2025); see https://www.pwc.com; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 2:15am
Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP), Chapter 12.
Regulatory frameworks for AI and automation; https://www.seahpublications.org; Accessed on 9/10/25 at 3:15am
Nkoro, “Digital Transformation and the Nigerian Economy” (2020) (arguing that a robust legal framework is necessary for Nigeria to benefit from digital transformation); see https://ru.scribd.com; Accessed on 20/9/2025 at 1am
Tony Elumelu Foundation, “Nigeria’s Startup Ecosystem” (2020); see https://www.tonyelumelufoundation.org; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 4am
Trademark Law Treaty, Article 2.
Trademarks Act, Cap. T13, LFN 2023 (Nigeria).
UK, Value Added Tax Act 1994.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, “Digital Economy Report 2020: Africa” (2020).
United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), Article 19.11.
US, Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA).
US, Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement.
Virtual mediation and online arbitration platforms in Nigeria; https://oal.law; Accessed on 1/10/25 at 2:30am
World Bank report on digital financial literacy; https://microdata.unhcr.org; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 10:16am
World Bank, “Digital Economy Report 2020: Nigeria” (2020).
World Economic Forum report on job displacement and automation, 2025; https://www.weforum.org; Accessed on 8/10/25 at 2:15am
World Intellectual Property Organization, “Copyright in the Digital Environment” (2020).
World Intellectual Property Organization, “Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights in the Digital Environment” (2021); https://www.uspto.gov; Accessed on 4/10/25 at 12:46am
World Intellectual Property Organization, “Enforcing Intellectual Property Rights” (2020).
World Trade Organization, “World Trade Report 2018: The Future of World Trade” (2018).
WTO governance and cross-border data flows.
WTO reform and digital trade; https://www.wto.org; Accessed 18/10/2025 at 1:05am
[2] Federal Republic of Nigeria, “National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy” (2020).
[3] OECD, “Digital Economy Outlook 2020” (2020).
[4] World Trade Organization, “World Trade Report 2018: The Future of World Trade” (2018).
[5] United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, “Digital Economy Report 2020: Africa” (2020).
[6] S. Nkoro, “Digital Transformation and the Nigerian Economy” (2020) (arguing that a robust legal framework is necessary for Nigeria to benefit from digital transformation); see https://ru.scribd.com; Accessed on 20/9/2025 at 1am
[7] C. Reed, “Making Laws for the Digital Economy” (2019) (emphasizing the importance of a well-designed legal framework for digital trade); AI overview; Accessed on 20/9/2025 at 1:15am
[8] Nigeria Communications Commission, “Internet Penetration in Nigeria” (2022).
[9] Nigeria Communications Commission, “Mobile Subscribers in Nigeria” (2022).
[10] Central Bank of Nigeria, “Digital Payments in Nigeria” (2022).
[11] McKinsey & Company, “Digital Transformation in Africa” (2020); see https://archive.umeca.org; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 1:30am
[12] PwC, “Global Consumer Insights Survey” (2025); see https://www.pwc.com; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 2:15am
[13] Federal Republic of Nigeria, “National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy” (2020 – 2030); see https://nitda.gov.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 3:15am
[14] Tony Elumelu Foundation, “Nigeria’s Startup Ecosystem” (2020); see https://www.tonyelumelufoundation.org; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 4am
[15] Ibid
[16] Prof. Amuda-Kannike SAN; Data Protection Laws in Nigeria: Impacts; see https://journals.kwasu.edu.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 5am
[17] Ibid
[18] Amuda-Kannike SAN et al; The intersection of technology…; see https://journals.unizik.edu.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 7am
[19] Ibid
[20] Ibid
[21] Amuda-Kannike SAN; Data Protection; Aremu Commends Amuda-Kannike on paper; see https://independent.ng; Accessed on 20/9/25 at 10am.
[22] Cybercrimes (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act 2015.
[23] Ibid
[24] National Information Technology Development Agency, “Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019” (2019).
[25] Electronic Transactions Act, 2023.
[26] Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act, 2018.
[27] Ibid
[28] National Information Technology Development Agency, “Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019” (2019).
[29] Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act, 2018.
[30] Income Tax Act, Cap. I8, LFN 2004 (Nigeria).
[31] Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019, which provides some guidelines on cross-border data transfers, but is limited in scope.
[32] Ibid
[33] Ibid
[34] Ibid
[35] Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act, 2018.
[36] Ibid
[37] Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019.
[38] Ibid
[39] Central Bank of Nigeria, “Fintech Regulatory Framework”; see https://www.globallegalsights.com; Accessed on 22/09/25 at 3am.
[40] Ibid
[41] OECD, “Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)”; see https://www.oecd.org; Accessed on 23/09/25 at 1:05am
[42] Ibid
[43] Ibid
[44] Ibid
[45] Ibid
[46] Ibid
[47] Ibid
[48] Ibid
[49] Ibid
[50] Ibid
[51] Ibid
[52] Evidence Act 2011; Cybercrimes Act 2015.
[53] Nigerian courts’ decisions on online contracts; https://law.unn.edu.ng; Accessed on 1/10/25 at 2:05am
[54] Ibid
[55] Virtual mediation and online arbitration platforms in Nigeria; https://oal.law; Accessed on 1/10/25 at 2:30am
[56]Ibid
[57] Ibid
[58] Lack of comprehensive digital trade legislation in Nigeria; https://aamdalelaw.com; Accessed on 1/10/25 at 3am.
[59] Ibid
[60] Ibid
[61] Ike Oraegbunam, P.I. Ozioko; Protection of Data Base and Computer Generated Works under the Nigerian law; see IJOCLLEP 3, 38, 2021.
[62] Ibid
[63] Nigeria Data Protection Regulation 2019, Section 5.
[64] Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act, 2018, Section 17.
[65] Nigeria Data Protection Act (NDPA) 2023.
[66] Nigeria Data Protection Commission (NDPC), “About Us”; https://ndpc.gov.ng; Accessed 2/10/25 at 2am.
[67] General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), EU 2016/679.
[68] Ibid
[69] Ibid
[70] Emerging technologies and data protection report 2025; https://www.cyberark.com; Accessed on 2/10/2025 at 3:15am
[71] ISO 27001, Information Security Management System; https://www.alison.com; Accessed on 3/10/25 at 3am
[72] General Data Protection Regulation, Article 6.
[73] Ibid
[74] International Chamber of Commerce, “Digital Piracy Report” (2020); https://iccwbo.org; Accessed on 3/10/25 at 3:40am
[75] World Intellectual Property Organization, “Copyright in the Digital Environment” (2020).
[76] Trademark Law Treaty, Article 2.
[77] Patents and Designs Act, Cap. P2, LFN 2022 (Nigeria).
[78] Copyright Act, Cap. C28, LFN 2022 (Nigeria).
[79] Trademarks Act, Cap. T13, LFN 2023 (Nigeria).
[80] Ibid
[81] World Intellectual Property Organization, “Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights in the Digital Environment” (2021); https://www.uspto.gov; Accessed on 4/10/25 at 12:46am
[82] Blockchain and intellectual property report; https://www.wipo.int; Accessed on 4/10/25 at 1:05am
[83] Ibid
[84] World Intellectual Property Organization, “Registering Intellectual Property Rights” (2020).
[85] Best practices for contracts and agreements in digital business.
[86] World Intellectual Property Organization, “Enforcing Intellectual Property Rights” (2020).
[87] Ibid
[88] Nigeria, Finance Act 2023.
[89] European Commission, “Digital Services Tax” (2020).
[90] Ibid.
[91] US, Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA).
[92] Ibid
[93] UK, Value Added Tax Act 1994.
[94] India, Goods and Services Tax Act 2017.
[95] US, Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement.
[96] Ibid
[97] Ibid
[98] IMF, “Digital Trade Taxation”; https://www.imf.org; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 2:03am
[99] Ibid
[100] Ibid
[101] OECD, “Technology and Tax Administration”; https://www.oecd.org; Accessed on 6/10/2025 at 4:02am
[102] Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), “Emerging Threats”; https://www.europa.eu; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 6:06am.
[103] AI-powered phishing campaigns.
[104] Ransomware attacks on healthcare organizations.
[105] Deepfake scams targeting executives.
[106] Cloud security breaches and data loss.
[107] IoT attacks and botnets.
[108] Supply chain attacks and ecosystem compromise.
[109] Social engineering tactics and phishing.
[110] Zero-day exploits and vulnerability management.
[111] Multi-factor authentication and encryption.
[112] Security audits and penetration testing.
[113] Ibid
[114] Ibid
[115] Ibid
[116] Ibid
[117] Ibid
[118] Ibid
[119] Financial Action Task Force (FATF) recommendations on AML/KYC; https://www.fatf.gafi.org; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 6:15am.
[120] Ibid
[121] Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) guidelines on payment services; https://www.consumerfinance.gov; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 8:30am
[122] Ibid
[123] Ibid
[124] World Bank report on digital financial literacy; https://microdata.unhcr.org; Accessed on 6/10/25 at 10:16am
[125] Ibid
[126] Ibid
[127] Ibid
[128] Ibid
[129] Ibid
[130] Ibid
[131] Google Translate and language translation tools; https://translate.google.com; Accessed 7/10/25 at 12:45pm
[132] Supply chain automation and logistics.
[133] Robotic process automation (RPA) in business.
[134] Digital workflows and collaboration tools.
[135] Benefits of AI and automation in digital trade.
[136] AI-powered customer support and experience.
[137] World Economic Forum report on job displacement and automation, 2025; https://www.weforum.org; Accessed on 8/10/25 at 2:15am
[138] Ibid
[139] Regulatory frameworks for AI and automation; https://www.seahpublications.org; Accessed on 9/10/25 at 3:15am
[140] Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), Article 14.11.
[141] United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), Article 19.11.
[142] Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP), Chapter 12.
[143] EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR); https://gdpr.info.eu; Accessed on 17/10/25 at 2:27am
[144] Balancing free flow and regulation in digital trade.
[145] Divergent regulatory frameworks for cross-border data flows.
[146] WTO governance and cross-border data flows.
[147] International cooperation on cross-border data flows.
[148] Regulatory convergence and digital trade agreements.
[149] WTO reform and digital trade; https://www.wto.org; Accessed 18/10/2025 at 1:05am
The post The Future Of Trade In Digital Transformation In Nigeria: The Legal Effects appeared first on TheNigeriaLawyer.
